Breakeven Math Calculators
State cost comparison Income Tax • Property Tax • MUD/PID Bonds • Insurance Surcharges

State-to-State Tax & Relocation Savings Modeler

Maintained by PavanKumar S · Figures checked against the Tax Foundation's 2026 tables of state income tax rates, sales tax rates and property taxes on November 14, 2026 · How figures are checked

Calculate your true net financial gain after moving, factoring in hidden homeownership taxes and insurance spikes in Texas, Florida, and Washington.

1. Income & Relocation Route

Move Specs

2. Real Estate & Hidden Taxes

Property & Insurance
⚠️ Factor In Local Real Estate Hidden Surcharges:
Yearly difference in these costs

+$4,116 / Year Gain

$343 a month lower in these costs
Income Tax Saved

+$13,600

0% State Tax
Property Tax Hike

-$4,900

High TX/FL Rates
Insurance & MUD

-$2,500

Special Levies
10-Yr Compounded

$56,868

@ 7% S&P 500
The Tax-Free State Reality Check:

While moving to Texas saves $13,600 in California income tax, your property tax rises from $4,900 to $9,800 in Texas (1.40% rate), plus $2,500 in suburban MUD bonds. The net difference is +$4,116/yr.

Total Annual State & Local Tax Stack

Income Tax + Property Tax + Sales Tax + Surcharges
Tax Burden
State taxes and housing costs

Moving to a state without income tax: property tax, insurance and other costs in Texas and Florida

An engineering breakdown of effective total tax burdens, MUD bonds, hurricane insurance crises, and California FTB clawbacks.

Every State Gets Its Money

No state is free. States that don’t collect personal income tax must fund roads, police, and schools through higher property taxes, sales taxes, and utility district bonds. For homeowners earning under $175,000, the high property taxes and insurance bills in Texas and Florida often equal or exceed what they would have paid in income tax in states with lower property taxes.

Frequently Asked Questions (Tax-Free States & Relocation)

How does California's FTB audit people who move away?

The California Franchise Tax Board (FTB) reviews residency when a taxpayer reports leaving California. Under California's "closest connections" test, they examine: 1) Days physically spent in CA vs outside, 2) Where your primary residence, family, doctors, and bank accounts are located, and 3) Whether you retained a home or country club membership in California.

What is a Texas MUD or PID tax?

A Municipal Utility District (MUD) or Public Improvement District (PID) is a special taxing entity created by real estate developers in Texas suburbs (Dallas, Houston, Austin) to finance water, sewage, and roads. Each district sets its own rate, which is charged on top of county property taxes; the MUD input here is an assumption, to be replaced with the district rate on the property's tax statement.

Comprehensive Guide to State Tax Relocation

Educational estimate, not advice. Figures are illustrative; consult a professional for your situation.

What this calculator does

This calculator compares the main state and local costs of living in two states: state income tax, property tax on the home, sales tax on taxable spending, and a homeowners insurance premium, with optional inputs for Texas MUD and PID assessments and Florida insurance. From household income, filing status, home value and taxable spending, it reports the yearly difference between the two states and what that difference would grow to over ten years if invested.

How the math works

The tool adds up four costs in each state: state income tax, property tax, sales tax and a homeowners insurance premium, plus the optional Texas MUD/PID and Florida insurance inputs. Income tax is one assumed average rate for each state and filing status, applied to gross income at every income level; it is not calculated from the 2026 brackets, so read that line as a rough estimate. The table below shows the rate the tool applies next to each state’s 2026 top rate. Property tax uses each state’s average effective rate on owner-occupied housing, which runs below what a new buyer pays in states such as California, where assessments of long-held homes are capped. Sales tax uses the combined state and average local rate as of 1 January 2026. The insurance premiums are the tool’s own assumptions and are not sourced. State and local taxes can also change your federal return through the SALT deduction, which this tool does not model; see IRS Publication 17.

State2026 top income tax rateIncome rate the tool applies, married / single (assumed)Combined sales tax, 1 Jan 2026Effective property tax, 2024Insurance premium (assumed)
California13.3%6.80% / 8.20%8.99%0.70%$1,800
New York10.9%5.50% / 6.50%8.54%1.30%$2,100
New Jersey10.75%5.20% / 6.20%6.60%1.88%$1,950
Massachusetts9.0%5.00% / 5.00%6.25%1.00%$1,800
Illinois4.95% flat4.95% / 4.95%8.96%1.88%$2,200
Minnesota9.85%5.80% / 6.80%8.14%1.00%$2,100
Oregon9.9%7.50% / 8.50%0.00%0.81%$1,600
Virginia5.75%5.20% / 5.40%5.77%0.78%$1,650
North Carolina3.99% flat3.99% / 3.99%7.00%0.66%$1,900
Colorado4.40% flat4.40% / 4.40%7.89%0.50%$2,800
TexasNone—8.20%1.40%$4,200
FloridaNone—6.98%0.78%$5,500
WashingtonNone on wages—9.51%0.75%$1,750
NevadaNone—8.24%0.50%$1,900
TennesseeNone—9.61%0.52%$2,200

Sources: top rates from the Tax Foundation’s State Individual Income Tax Rates and Brackets, 2026 (North Carolina’s 3.99% also from the NCDOR tax rate schedules); sales tax from State and Local Sales Tax Rates, 2026; property tax from Property Taxes by State and County, 2026, which is built on American Community Survey data. Washington taxes capital gains but not wages.

Worked example

Take a married couple earning $200,000 a year who move from California to Texas, buy a $700,000 home and spend $40,000 a year on taxable purchases. These are the calculator’s default inputs. In California the tool applies its assumed 6.8% average rate, $13,600 of income tax, plus $4,900 of property tax (0.70%), $3,596 of sales tax (8.99%) and an assumed $1,800 insurance premium, for a total of $23,896. In Texas there is no state income tax, but property tax on the same home is $9,800 (1.40%), sales tax is $3,280 (8.20%), the assumed insurance premium is $4,200 and the MUD bond adds $2,500, for a total of $19,780. The difference is $4,116 a year, less than a third of the $13,600 income tax saving on its own. The 6.8% is the tool’s assumption, not a bracket calculation; California’s 2026 rates run from 1% to 13.3%, so a couple’s actual California tax at this income can differ from it.

How to read the result

The yearly difference adds up four kinds of cost in each state and subtracts one total from the other; a positive figure means those costs are lower in the destination. It is an estimate built on averages: income tax uses one assumed rate per state and filing status rather than the brackets, property tax uses each state's average effective rate, and insurance premiums are the tool's own assumptions. The ten-year figure is that yearly difference invested at an assumed 7%, not a forecast of taxes.

Income and home value move the result most, in opposite directions. At the defaults (a married couple on $200,000 moving from California to Texas with a $700,000 home), the yearly difference is $4,116. At $300,000 of income it rises to $10,916, because the income tax saving grows with income. A $1,000,000 home cuts it to $2,016, because the property tax rate is higher in Texas. The $2,500 MUD assessment alone is more than half the default difference.

Sources

Sources checked October 2026. The income tax rates the tool applies and the insurance premiums are assumptions, shown in the table above.

Common mistakes

Frequently Asked Questions

Does moving to a 0% income tax state always save me money?

Not always. States without an income tax must generate revenue through other means. This often results in significantly higher property taxes, elevated sales taxes, or special assessments like MUD bonds. Depending on your housing budget and spending, these hidden costs can exceed your income tax savings.

How do Florida's housing costs impact relocation savings?

Florida has no state income tax, so for a homeowner the comparison turns largely on property tax and insurance. This calculator applies an assumed $5,500 homeowners premium for Florida, the highest of the states listed, and the Florida insurance input can replace it with a quote. Homes in high-risk flood zones bought with a federally backed mortgage must also carry flood insurance, which is not included.

What is a Texas MUD tax?

A Municipal Utility District (MUD) tax is a special assessment used to fund local infrastructure like water and sewage in many Texas suburbs. This tax is levied on top of your standard county property taxes and can add thousands of dollars to your annual housing costs.

Can my former state audit me after I move?

A former state can question whether a move changed residency for tax purposes, especially for high earners and for income such as stock compensation earned before the move. States generally look at where a person lives, keeps a home, works, and spends time; the rules and day counts differ by state, so the former state's own guidance sets the test.

Disclaimer: Educational and scenario-analysis use only; not tax, legal, or investment advice. Consult a licensed CPA or tax advisor for your specific situation. Figures reflect 2026 statutory limits and may change.

Sales and property tax rates as sourced above; income tax rates are the tool’s stated assumptions.

Related tools: Try our W2 vs 1099 Calculator, ISO/AMT Stock Options Calculator, Tech Offer Total Compensation Calculator, Rent Increase vs. Moving Cost Calculator, and Tax-Loss Harvesting Calculator.