Breakeven Math Calculators

ISO vs. NSO Stock Options & AMT Calculator

Maintained by PavanKumar S · Figures checked against Rev. Procs. 2023-34, 2024-40 and 2025-32, IRS Publications 15 and 525, FTB Schedule P (540) and Minnesota Schedule M1MT on November 14, 2026 · How figures are checked

Updated for tax year 2026 (OBBBA rules). All calculations run in your browser; nothing you enter is sent to a server.

Quick Presets — Click any preset to test immediately

Select a Startup Equity Scenario or customize below:

Estimated AMT-free exercise capacity

Based on your income, you can exercise up to 3,914 shares ($35,226.00 spread) this year with zero Alternative Minimum Tax.

Assumes entered income, standard exemption, and no other preference items.

Exercise & Income Details

Simple Mode
10,000 shares
$
$
Total Exercise Spread (FMV − Strike): $90,000.00
$150,000.00
$

Immediate Exercise Cash Outlay Check to Write Today

Tax Year: 2026
ISO (Incentive)
ISO Exercise & Hold
Strike Exercise Cost: $10,000.00
Federal AMT Due: $14,240.00
State AMT Due (CA): $0.00
FICA / Payroll Tax: $0.00 (Exempt)
Total Cash Outlay Required
$24,240.00

Generates $14,240.00 in Form 8801 Minimum Tax Credits for future recovery.

NSO (Non-Qual)
NSO Exercise & Hold
Strike Exercise Cost: $10,000.00
Federal Ordinary Tax: $23,370.00
State Income Tax: $8,370.00
FICA / Medicare Tax: $3,804.00
Total Cash Outlay Required
$45,544.00

Tax establishes full regular basis ($10.00/sh). Zero AMT credit generated.

ISO needs less cash at exercise: ISO requires $21,304.00 less cash today than NSO.

Visual Tax Analysis

Full Lifecycle Exit & Take-Home Gain (at $30.00 Exit)

Category ISO (Qualifying Hold) NSO Difference / Benefit
Gross Sale Proceeds $300,000.00 $300,000.00 $0
Tax at Exercise (Year 1) $14,240.00 $35,544.00 +$21,304.00 (ISO lower)
Tax at Future Sale (Year 2+) $79,590.00 $54,300.00 -$25,290.00
Form 8801 AMT Credit Recovery +$14,240.00 N/A +$14,240.00
Net Total Take-Home Profit $210,410.00 $200,156.00 +$10,254.00 (ISO higher)

Educational estimate, not advice. Figures are illustrative; consult a professional for your situation.

What this calculator does

This calculator compares exercising incentive stock options (ISOs) with exercising non-qualified stock options (NSOs) on the same grant. From the salary, strike price, fair market value and number of shares, it estimates the cash needed at exercise for each: the strike price plus the alternative minimum tax (AMT) an ISO exercise can trigger, or the income and payroll tax an NSO exercise does. It then carries both to a sale price to compare the tax at sale and the net proceeds.

It also estimates how many ISO shares can be exercised in the year before AMT applies at all. The figures are federal and state estimates for one tax year from the inputs given; they do not replace the Form 6251 calculation on a full return.

How the math works

The calculations follow the statutory mechanisms outlined in IRC §55 and IRS Form 6251. For the 2026 tax year, the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) calculation requires adding back the bargain element (the difference between the FMV and your strike price) of your ISOs to your ordinary income to determine your Alternative Minimum Taxable Income (AMTI).

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA, signed July 4, 2025) changed this calculation starting in tax year 2026. It made the higher AMT exemption amounts permanent ($90,100 for single filers and $140,200 for married filing jointly in 2026, indexed for inflation), reset the exemption phase-out thresholds to $500,000 and $1,000,000 respectively, and doubled the phase-out rate from 25% to 50%. The practical effect is that a large ISO spread now erases the exemption much faster than it did under 2025 rules, and the calculator applies the phase-out automatically based on the tax year you select.

If you hold your ISOs for a qualifying disposition—which strictly requires holding the shares for at least two years from the grant date and one year from the exercise date—your final gains may be taxed at favorable long-term capital gains rates. If you pay AMT upon exercise, you may generate a Minimum Tax Credit (MTC). However, recovery of this credit via Form 8801 depends entirely on your future tax years' ordinary liability exceeding your AMT liability; it is not an immediate refund.

Worked example

Take the High AMT Spread preset above: 15,000 options at a $1.00 strike, a $35.00 current FMV, and $200,000 of ordinary income (single filer, 2026). The bargain element is $34.00 per share, so the total spread is 15,000 × $34 = $510,000, and exercising costs $15,000 in strike price alone.

On the regular side, the $16,100 standard deduction leaves $183,900 taxable, which runs through the 2026 single brackets to $36,734. On the AMT side, AMTI is $200,000 + $510,000 = $710,000. That is $210,000 above the $500,000 OBBBA phase-out threshold, and at the 50% phase-out rate it erases $105,000 of exemption — more than the $90,100 available, so the exemption floors at zero and the full $710,000 is the AMT base. Tentative Minimum Tax is therefore ($244,500 × 26%) + ($465,500 × 28%) = $193,910, and the AMT actually owed is the excess over regular tax: $157,176.

Step Arithmetic Result
ISO spread 15,000 × ($35.00 − $1.00) $510,000
Regular tax brackets on ($200,000 − $16,100) $36,734
AMTI $200,000 + $510,000 $710,000
Exemption after phase-out $90,100 − (($710,000 − $500,000) × 50%) $0
Tentative Minimum Tax ($244,500 × 26%) + ($465,500 × 28%) $193,910
Federal AMT owed $193,910 − $36,734 $157,176

Federal cash needed at exercise is the $15,000 strike plus $157,176 of AMT. Any state AMT (California and Minnesota, for example) is layered on top of this figure by the calculator.

ISO vs NSO at a glance

The calculator models the tax mechanics, but several rules decide which type of option you actually hold and whether it keeps its status. These are the ones that most often surprise people.

Rule ISO (incentive stock option) NSO (non-qualified stock option)
Who can receive them Employees only Employees, contractors, advisors, directors
Tax at exercise No regular income tax or FICA. The spread is an AMT preference item (Form 6251). Spread is ordinary wage income, subject to federal, state, and FICA tax, with withholding at exercise.
Basis in the shares Regular basis is the strike price; AMT basis is the FMV at exercise (this is what later frees the Form 8801 credit). FMV at exercise, since the spread was already taxed.
Tax at sale Qualifying disposition (2 years from grant and 1 year from exercise): entire gain over strike is long-term capital gain. Sell earlier and the spread becomes ordinary income. Gain over FMV-at-exercise is capital gain; long-term if held more than one year after exercise.
$100,000 limit Only $100,000 of ISOs (measured at grant-date FMV) may first become exercisable in any calendar year. Anything above that is treated as NSOs, and companies often issue "split" grants for this reason. No limit.
After you leave the company Must be exercised within 3 months of termination (12 months for disability) to keep ISO treatment. Longer post-termination windows are common, but the options convert to NSOs once the 3 months pass. Whatever window the plan allows, with no change in tax character.
Company tax deduction None on a qualifying disposition, which is why some employers prefer to grant NSOs. Deducts the spread as compensation expense.

When NSOs come out ahead

The default comparison favours ISOs because the reader keeps the shares long enough for a qualifying disposition, but that is not always the realistic case. Use the Advanced panel to test these situations, where the NSO column often comes out ahead or the gap disappears:

  • You expect to sell within a year of exercising. A disqualifying ISO disposition taxes the spread as ordinary income anyway, so the ISO advantage collapses to the FICA saving, and any AMT already paid becomes a credit you must wait to recover.
  • The spread is small. With little or no AMT exposure, the ISO's main benefit is minor, while the NSO gives you a full-basis step-up and simpler reporting.
  • You are already deep into AMT. Every extra dollar of spread is taxed at 26% or 28% now, and the Form 8801 credit can take many years to come back if your regular tax stays close to your tentative minimum tax.
  • You need the cash. An NSO exercise with a same-day sale (a cashless exercise) requires no money down; an ISO exercise-and-hold requires the strike plus any AMT out of pocket, which is why exercise financing exists.

The lifecycle table above is the place to compare these, since it nets the tax at exercise, the tax at sale, and the credit recovery into a single take-home figure for each type.

How to read the result

Two different comparisons sit on the page. The cash at exercise compares this year: an ISO exercise adds no regular income but can trigger AMT on the spread, while an NSO exercise adds the whole spread to wages, with income and payroll tax due now. The lifecycle table compares the whole path to a sale, including the minimum tax credit an ISO exercise can create; that credit is recovered only in later years when regular tax exceeds the tentative minimum tax, so the ISO net figure assumes it is eventually used.

The spread moves everything. At the defaults (10,000 shares, $1 strike, $10 value, $150,000 salary, single, 2026), the $90,000 spread brings $14,240 of federal AMT, and the ISO exercise needs $24,240 of cash against $45,544 for an NSO. At a $20 value the spread is $190,000 and federal AMT is $40,348. The zero-AMT figure, 3,914 shares here, is the most that can be exercised this year without AMT; exercising exactly that many produces none.

Sources

Corrected October 2, 2026, the day the site went live and before it was indexed or announced: negative amounts were shown as “$-25,290”, and a callout labelled the cash gap at exercise as AMT. Both were fixed. See the corrections log.

Corrected November 14, 2026: head of household and married filing separately returns were taxed on the single-filer brackets, and married filing separately used the $200,000 Additional Medicare Tax threshold instead of $125,000 and the single-filer California and Minnesota AMT exemptions. Each status now uses its own figures from Rev. Procs. 2023-34, 2024-40 and 2025-32, IRC section 3101(b)(2), FTB Schedule P (540) and Minnesota Schedule M1MT. See the corrections log.

Sources checked October 2026. The 2026 Form 6251 instructions had not been published; the 2026 exemption and phase-out figures come from the OBBBA changes and Rev. Proc. 2025-32.

Common mistakes

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I owe AMT if I exercise ISOs but don't sell?
Yes, you might. Even if you do not sell the shares, the "spread" (the difference between the FMV and your strike price) is treated as a preference item for AMT purposes in the year you exercise.
What happens if I sell my ISOs in the same year I exercise them?
This is known as a disqualifying disposition. The spread at exercise will be taxed as ordinary income, completely eliminating the potential AMT preference item and negating the favorable ISO tax treatment.
When do I actually get the Form 8801 AMT credit back?
The AMT credit recovery timing is strictly dependent on your future tax profiles. You can only use the credit in years where your ordinary tax liability is higher than your calculated AMT. It is carried forward until exhausted and may not be recovered immediately.
Can an 83(b) election be used with ISOs?
Yes, if the company allows early exercise of unvested options. Filing an 83(b) election within 30 days of exercising treats the shares as received on the exercise date, so the AMT preference (for ISOs) or ordinary income (for NSOs) is measured then. If you exercise while the FMV is still close to the strike price, that spread is near zero, which is the whole point. The trade-off is that you pay the strike price for shares that may never vest, and the 30-day deadline has no extension.

Published by Breakeven Math, an independent publisher of financial calculators. Built and maintained by a software engineer, not by a tax professional.

The figures on this page are taken from IRS publications and the OBBBA statute, and the worked examples are regenerated from the calculator's own code whenever a figure changes. Treat the results as a starting point for a conversation with your CPA, not a substitute for one.

How the figures are checked.