What this calculator does
This calculator compares an existing mortgage with a refinance at a lower rate, the situation that often follows a run of Federal Reserve rate cuts. It takes the current balance, rate and years remaining, a new rate and term, and the closing costs, and reports the change in the monthly payment, the months until that change repays the closing costs, the five-year net, and the difference in remaining interest. It also shows how much sooner the new loan would be repaid if the old payment kept being made.
How the math works
The underlying calculation relies on standard mortgage amortization formulas to determine both your current and projected monthly principal and interest (P&I) payments. The fundamental equation used to calculate a monthly payment is \( P \times \frac{r(1+r)^n}{(1+r)^n-1} \), where \( P \) is the loan principal, \( r \) is the monthly interest rate, and \( n \) is the total number of payments.
When computing the break-even timeline, the calculator divides the total estimated closing costs (such as origination fees, appraisal, and title insurance) by the monthly savings generated from the new lower interest rate. This metric indicates how many months it will take to recover your upfront investment. For authoritative guidance on mortgage calculations and lending disclosures, refer to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) mortgage resources.
Deep dive: Jackson Hole Fed Rate Cuts: The 2026 Monetary Pivot, 10-Year Yields, and the Mortgage Refinance Window.
Deep dive: How the Financial Machine Works: From Uncle Sam to Family Man — why the rate that sets your mortgage payment gets set at all.
Worked example
The defaults describe a $450,000 balance at 7.125% with 27 years left, refinanced into a new 30-year loan at 6.125% with $8,000 of closing costs paid in cash. The current payment is $3,132 and the new one $2,734, $398 a month less. Closing costs divided by that saving gives a breakeven of 20.1 months, and five years of savings less the closing costs comes to $15,861. Over the full terms the new loan carries $30,416 less interest, a figure that does not subtract the closing costs and that reflects a loan running three years longer. Continuing to pay the old $3,132 on the new loan would retire it 8.3 years early.
How to read the result
The breakeven months answer the first question a refinance raises: how long the lower payment takes to repay the closing costs. A breakeven inside the time the loan will be kept means the refinance pays for itself in cash; a longer one means it does not. The remaining-interest difference is a second, longer view. It does not subtract closing costs, and when the new term is longer than the years left it compares loans of different lengths, so it can be positive while the borrower pays for longer.
The rate drop moves the result most. At the defaults (a full point, 7.125% to 6.125%), the payment falls $398 and the costs are repaid in 20.1 months. A half-point drop, to 6.625%, saves $251 a month, takes 31.9 months to repay the costs, and leaves $22,559 more interest over the new 30-year term than the 27 years left on the current loan. The new term changes the picture too: a 20-year term raises the payment by $125 but carries $233,191 less interest.
Sources
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, mortgage resources — disclosure rules for refinance terms and costs
- CFPB, What fees or charges are paid when closing on a mortgage — common closing costs, and lender credits paid for through rate or loan amount
- CFPB, What is a Closing Disclosure? — the form showing a refinance's final rate, payment and costs
Corrected October 2, 2026, the day the site went live and before it was indexed or announced: the “total payments” difference repeated the interest difference instead of comparing total payments, and the worked example was rewritten to match the calculator’s output. See the corrections log.
Sources checked October 2026. Payments come from the standard fixed-rate formula; no live rate data is used, and the new rate is an input.
Common mistakes
- Assuming a Fed cut moves mortgage rates by the same amount. The Federal Reserve sets an overnight bank rate; fixed mortgage rates track longer-term yields and can move before, after or against a cut.
- Counting the interest difference as savings. When the new term is longer than the years left, a lower rate can still mean more total interest; at a half-point drop the defaults show $22,559 more.
- Leaving closing costs out. The breakeven depends on them entirely, and costs rolled into the loan are repaid with interest over the new term.
- Ignoring how long the loan will be kept. A sale or another refinance before the breakeven month leaves the closing costs unrecovered.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do Federal Reserve rate cuts instantly lower mortgage rates?
No, the Federal Reserve sets the federal funds rate, which is the overnight borrowing rate for banks. Mortgage rates are largely tied to the 10-year Treasury yield. However, anticipation of Fed rate cuts often causes Treasury yields—and subsequently mortgage rates—to drop before the Fed officially acts.
When do mortgage discount points pay off?
Paying discount points involves upfront cash to permanently reduce your interest rate. This makes sense if you plan to keep the mortgage for a long time. You can evaluate this trade-off using a discount points break-even calculator to see when the upfront cost pays off.
Is it better to refinance or recast a mortgage?
Only a refinance changes the interest rate. A mortgage recast keeps your current interest rate but recalculates your monthly payment based on a large lump-sum principal reduction. Compare both options with a recast vs. refinance calculator.
What happens if the old payment keeps being paid after refinancing?
The extra amount goes to principal, so the new loan is repaid early. At the defaults, paying the old $3,132 on the new 6.125% loan instead of the required $2,734 retires it 8.3 years before its 30-year term, which is about five years sooner than the 27 years left on the current loan.
Related Tools
Disclaimer: This tool is provided for educational and scenario-analysis purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, tax, or investment advice. Breakeven Math does not guarantee the accuracy or applicability of these projections to your specific circumstances. Mortgage rates, closing costs, and tax implications vary widely. Always consult a licensed CPA, financial advisor, or mortgage professional before making financial decisions. Figures reflect 2026 economic parameters and may change.